Show Business, watercolor by Kelly Eddington, 2026. Based on a screenshot from The Greatest Show on Earth.
Blind Date With The Carnaval
Kelly Eddington
Have you ever been on a blind date?
Listening to a new U2 album for the first time is about as close as you can get to that. Let me explain.
First, you’ve got to imagine that U2 is a little family.
Bono: the all-caps MOTHER
Edge: the genius father
Adam: the sweet and achingly cool uncle
Larry: the brutally honest, deadpan hilarious uncle
Their albums are their sons. You’ve loved these sons, some more than others, for most of your life, and over the years you’ve maintained healthy relationships with all of them. But the family knows you love to be introduced to new sons, and it’s been nine years since the last one.
They’ve spent the past ten months hyping their youngest son to you. They say he is special. While he has all the beloved hallmarks of their other sons, they assure you he’s like no one you’ve ever met, and he possesses the gift of defiant joy. He will be a comfort to you during these troubled times.
“Oh! But first, have you met the twins?”
“I really like them, but they’re kind of short.”
“Not to worry. Our new, proper son will meet you on November 13.”
But that’s, like, practically winter. So while you wait, you try to find out as much as you can about this son. The family drops hints from time to time. In June, they release a photo—a video!—of him.
Uncredited photo from U2.com
And you like his looks, but he seems a tiny bit…simple? Is that the right word? Are you jumping to conclusions based on this lone tidbit of information? You shouldn’t do that. Despite its simplicity or whatever it is, this tidbit will stay firmly lodged in your imagination for the entire summer.
Then, on the eve of the family’s epic fiftieth anniversary celebration, they release another video of the new son.
Screenshot from Silencio, and I don’t know why it’s small.
Like the twins, and like the family’s mother, the video is kind of short, but this is something you can really get behind! Maybe the new son is more of a badass than you thought…? You are dying to meet him while the family spends hour upon hour revisiting stories about the good old days. You can’t begrudge them that because fifty years is an unimaginable milestone, and they’re such an adorable family you can’t even believe it sometimes.
Then, about a month before you and the new son will finally meet, you receive the following love letter from him:
Screenshot from The Greatest Show on Earth. I almost painted this one. I still could, I suppose!
Holy shit. Turns out he’s a genius and romantic and blessedly weird. Your expectations are sky high, and you worry that maybe nothing else about him will measure up to this love letter. While you continue to wait, you admire the new, almost daily photos and interview snippets of his family as they talk about each other and their new son.
Photo by Philip Montgomery for the New York Times. Bless you, Philip Montgomery.
And then and then and THEN the day comes and you finally get to meet him!
Oh my god, he’s pulling up to the curb in a spectacular car that’s been painted something like two dozen different colors. His driver wears a mask that vaguely resembles his cool uncle’s face, and the car’s stereo is blasting samba music.
Go (Carnaval De Luz)
He swaggers into the coffee shop and smiles at you. He is gorgeous and strange, and this first impression exceeds your expectations in every way. Miraculous!
La Reina
You can just tell when a man adores women. Studying you with his father’s curiosity, he asks, “May I?” before he kisses your hand. Then he wants to know everything about you.
Street of Dreams
He tells a simple little joke to lighten the mood because he understands how intense he can be. And you’ve got to admit he’s dangerously cute when he starts talking about following dreams. Is that a Spanish accent, or maybe Portuguese?
The Mirror Maker (Rosalia)
He confesses that he’s a big fan of a certain musician, and it’s reached the point where he, uh, makes things as a sort of tribute to her. This humanizes him even more in your eyes, and it makes your own weirdass, decades-long art project regarding his family seem marginally less insane.
Superficiality
He’s actually goofy at times…? He's not shy about speaking in a really high voice at times…? You don’t know if you like the way he pronounces “superfiseeality,” but let’s face it, you are falling in love with him. The rose-colored glasses are on. Incidentally, while you’ve never been nuts about round glasses, if he has to wear them, at least his are kind of pretty. You notice your beaming reflection inside their lenses.
If the World is at War We Better Not Be
Aww, he was talking about his friends for just a minute there, and now he’s getting contemplative and using really long acronyms, such as ITWIAWWBNB. He’s awfully earnest, isn’t he?
Silencio
OH HEY remember that second video his family sent you a couple of months ago? He’s making it clear that no matter how earnest he might be, and how much he talks about the sun and the moon and the devil (which he actually seems to believe in) he still wants to eat you alive. And he knows you like a little dirt in your sandwich.
The Greatest Show on Earth
Then he reminds you of why you love his family’s sons, and it’s becoming increasingly clear that he’s at least one of their top eight creations. You feel a twinge of regret that, thanks to the love letter, you already knew how impressive he was going into the date, and you wish you could have discovered it today. No matter. Your heart is soaring.
Glorify
Dude, some of the stuff he says reminds you of his mother SO MUCH. He definitely believes in God, and you kind of don’t, but just look at him. He is beyond blessed. How can he not believe in a higher power? His eyes sparkle behind his glasses as he speculates that God wants to glorify humanity. And even if you don’t believe in everything he’s talking about, just as a thought experiment, you try to apply what he’s saying to art, or how about sex? You luxuriate that deep, carnal voice of his. Yes, it’s completely obvious that glorify can have sexual connotations, and he could very well be talking about you and not You.
Midnight Sunshine
Your phones are blowing up with the usual bad news. Nevertheless, he is inviting you to his bedroom slash bunker. You know, whenever you’re ready. It doesn’t have to be today. He’s dropping plenty of hints that the two of you could have a lot of fun despite what’s going on in the world.
Can’t Stop Us Now
Mmm, he’s dreamy and kind of cocky, with that special brand of confidence that runs in the family. He’s artistic and doesn’t care if people won’t listen to him as much as some of his older brothers. He loves his life, and he wants you to be part of it. He wants the two of you to become an unstoppable Us.
Torn
So. Uh, wow. Yes. Afterward, he covers the two of you with a handmade, heirloom quilt, and it’s so beautiful you burst into tears.
In summation, 4.5/5 stars, K says check it out.
Uh, the other night before I went to sleep, I asked my brain to come up with a unique angle for my review of U2’s new album, and this is what it delivered. Last week when Edge said he woke up with a treatment for Elf 2 in his head one morning, I had never related to him more in my life. But Edge didn’t ask for Elf 2. I specifically ask my brain to do things. If I have a creative problem, I try to get my mind to solve it overnight. More often than not, it will wake me up during the wee hours with a solution. It’s actually awesome. You should try it!
Unfortunately, the above blind date metaphor didn’t allow me to discuss other ideas I’ve had about Carnaval De Luz. Example: I visualized the album as a rambling, caterpillar-like shape upon my first listen, and I sort of wanted to draw it. I also couldn’t mention the super fun couple of days PJ and I spent celebrating the album’s release at my house. Originally, we’d planned to write a review together in our usual “written podcast” format, but the above thing rolled out of me in one sitting yesterday, and it was too unweildy to fit that format. So I would like to thank PJ for being enthusiastic about me posting this independently, and she will write her own review later, and I don’t think I need to tell you that it will be excellent.
Thanks as always to my brain, my watercolors, my handsome husband Jeff, a Renaissance man/polymath I met almost 19 years ago in a coffee shop, and I fell in love with him with alarming speed, the parts of Bono that his mask didn’t cover, the U2 Corporation, the photographers and videographers whose work I borrowed here, and, of course, sumo wrestlers throughout the world.